Comment Home / Reviews

Poetry's next wave

The best of the new crop of poets are bridging the gap between avant-garde obscurantism and traditional narrative poetry. Consider the latest anthology from W.W. Norton, a browser's introduction to poetry today.
BOOK REVIEW: Cole Swenson and David St. John (editors), American Hybrid: A Norton Anthology of New Poetry. W.W. Norton, 2009. US$17.13/C$17.96. ISBN: 978-0393333756.
Madama Butterfly

Seventy-four poets' work is represented here, and all of it tethered to a single thesis (expounded eloquently in the introduction): poetry has moved past the aesthetic "schools" of the 20th century. There's no more war between avant-garde obscurantism (for example, Pound and Williams) and traditional narrative poetry (Frost and Lowell). The best of the new crop are making use of both innovative form and linear narrative, producing poems that are at once relevant and accessible—in some cases even popular.

That's the thesis, anyway. Do the poems support it?

At first blush, the answer seems to be yes. Aside from a few Gertrude Stein-like word-blocks in Etel Adnan's poems ("healed mansions of . . . / everybody's fate / in the balance . . . in / xeroxed (blank) / sheets shh"), and moments of indecipherable spaciness in Stephen Ratcliffe's writing, these poems read effortlessly but present slightly askew subject matter. Little intrusions—breaks in continuity, other voices, unexpected images—fill the writing with a kind of electricity of which simple narrative is not capable. It's postmodern! And yet it's not too terribly weird. These poems have the fairy-tale energy of Amelie. To wit:

          I'm afraid
          I don't love
          my mother
          who's dead

          though I once –
          what does "once" mean? –
          did love her.

          So who'll meet me over yonder?
          I don't recognize the place names.

          Or I do, but they come
          from televised wars.

That's from Rae Armantrout's "Yonder"—like most of the poems in this collection, spare and extremely easy to read.

What's harder to tell is if this is a representative sample. To my watching eye there are many glaring omissions. Billy Collins unfortunately has been out of fashion ever since he was appointed U.S. Poet Laureate by George W. Bush, so it's no surprise he's excluded. James Tate and Russell Edson would seem perfect candidates for inclusion, as would the younger poets Ange Mlinko and Matthea Harvey. And what about Gabriel Gudding? Gudding can be obscene, but he's brilliantly talented and fits the thesis. Campbell McGrath? Stephen Dobyns? Michael Dumanis?

A larger question, as far as American Hybrid's very existence goes, is whether the thesis is even profound or important. To poets actually working in the "hybrid" model, such historical observations might not even be vaguely interesting. The production of postmodern art and literature happens without—and despite—in fact, perhaps in reaction against—the critic's instinct to map such categories. For the postmodernist, revision and remapping is as banal as dialectical opposition. We're more interested, in a Heideggerian sense, in what is. And the space it takes up.

But there is no doubt at all that this book will be used in classrooms, and it can be enjoyed as a browser's introduction to what's being written now. In comparison to Paul Hoover's Postmodern American Poetry (1994), this volume is (refreshingly) thesis-driven; relative to Sarabande's Legitimate Dangers: American Poets of the New Century (2006), this collection seems much less cliquish.

Help us spread the word:
Aaron Belz Aaron Belz
Aaron Belz is a poet and essayist who has published work across a spectrum of journals. ... read more »

Posted in Arts.

Subscribe to the Comment Weekly Newsletter
Comment's online articles serve as bridges between print issues. Get an email in your inbox every Friday, so you don't miss out.
  • Stay up-to-date and informed
  • Only one concise digest email per week
  • We will never share your email address. No Spam!
We will never sell or rent your email address. Your privacy is important to us

Related Articles

We'd love to hear your comments. Tell us what you think of this article! We'll use the best comments in Comment's print edition, and top commenters each month will receive a free, signed copy of our editor's recent book: Discipleship in the Present Tense.

Copyright © 1974-2014 Cardus. All Rights Reserved.

Features

  1. What does rest look like for you this summer?

    July 24, 2014 | Norman Wirzba

    While Comment is usually interested in faith and work, we asked some of our favourite writers and friends to tell us how they are working at rest this summer.

Reviews

  1. Beyond "Engagement": The Next Conversation We Need About Politics

    May 1, 2014 | James K.A. Smith

    Looking elsewhere for the robust embrace of politics that will speak today—to our time and place and audience.
  2. Getting Back to Place

    April 24, 2014 | Doug Sikkema

    Because place has such a power to shape, we must be mindful of how we shape our places.

Interviews

  1. Inequality, Gentrification, and Justice: Continuing the Conversation with Jonathan Bradford

    June 26, 2014 | Jonathan Bradford with James K.A. Smith

    The human condition can put up with disconnection for only so long. We are critters who like to be in packs. We had thirty years of people trying to be away from one another. I ...

Cardus Blog

  1. Sages and Saints

    July 25, 2014 | Doug Sikkema

    "So just what are you going to do with that degree?"  If you're planning to enter university or college in a month or so, or maybe even just graduated this past spring and ar...
  2. Protests and the Police Force

    July 24, 2014 | Ray Pennings

    Although I've done it a few times, carrying a placard in a public protest really isn't my thing. That's not to say it isn't important or can't be effective. Washington, 1963. G...

Print Issue

  1. June 2014: The Other Side of the City
    Comment Magazine - The Other Side of the City There are all kinds of good reasons to embrace the city—as strategic placement for evangelism and urban mission, perhaps, or as centres of cultural influence to which hips...
Comment on iPad