Comment Home / Reviews & Opinions

Look Out for the Social Engineers

The campaign to eliminate discrimination in the workplace received a powerful boost with the publication last October of the Royal Commission Report on Equality in Employment by Judge Rosalie Silberman Abella. The Commission was appointed to inquire into the best means to promote equality in employment for four groups—women, native people, disabled persons and visible minorities.

Judge Abella is convinced that discriminatian is "systemic" in our society, and that it is reinforced by what she calls a stereotypical way of thinking about members of the four disadvantaged groups. She calls for systemic remedies, to be monitored and enforced by an agency somewhat like the Canadian Human Rights Commission. This agency would ensure that companies adopt the kind of hiring and promotion policies that will result in a "fair" representation of the target groups in their companies. Abella prefers the tenn "employment equity" to "affirmative action," since the latter smacks of governnent intervention and quotas. However, the outcome of Abella's recommendations will differ little from a quota system, because companies wi11 still be required to meet specific goals. Her proposals amount to a far-reaching change in policy that is bound to result in people being hired not on the basis of their qualifications, but on the basis of their belonging to the category of "disadvantaged."

The Equality in Employment Report presents the traditional role of women as homemakers and mothers as having been an obstacle to women's self-realization. Therefore Judge Abella recommends that childcare facilities be publicly funded and universally available. The report also takes aim at the notion that marriage and the family are institutions in which one spouse provides the economic support for the other. Instead, the report advocates a change in our perception of the family and in law so that spouses are considered to be completely financially independent of one another.

Judge Abella believes that an entirely new understanding of the relationship between men and women must be developed, beginning with the earliest training of children. She recommends that course material and textbooks in the schools be monitored "to make sure the discriminatory stereotypes are avoided."

It is obvious that Abella has drunk deeply from the well of collectivist thought. She admits that absolute equality may be impossible to achieve, but is convinced that this ideal should guide us in our efforts to shape society.

All of us should be concerned about unfair treatment of women the disabled and members of minority groups in the workplace. But we should also be alert to the fact that this Roya1 Commission seeks to use the 1aw and a powerful bureaucracy to bring about an egalitarian society. Those who treasure the freedom and integrity of societal institutions, notably the family, should not hesitate to reject the recommendations of this report.

Harry Antonides Harry Antonides
Harry Antonides is the founding editor of Comment. ... read more »


Add Your Comments


Copyright © 1974-2012 Cardus. All Rights Reserved.

| More

Feature Essays

  1. If Wishing Made it So: Teaching Students to Make Change

    May 14, 2012 | Gloria Stronks and Julia Stronks

    Parents and teachers want children to have the skills to make a difference. But what can we teach to help them survive their teen years, 20s, and 30s with convictions and charac...

Reviews & Opinions

  1. Do Not Open—No User Serviceable Parts Inside

    May 22, 2012 | David Greusel

    Why do so many of us have to work where the windows don't open? Engineers, architects, and lawyers have their reasons, but must workplaces be less humane than homes?
  2. Morality, markets, and Michael Sandel

    May 18, 2012 | Nick Spencer

    In Santa Ana in California prisoners can buy a cell upgrade. In Dallas, Texas, underachieving children are paid to read books. These are, alas, some of the saner and less offens...

Six Questions

  1. Saying "there is not enough time" is heresy

    May 2, 2012 | Stephanie Gehring

    SIX QUESTIONS . . . The new culture I am making is an attempt to say hold still and look at this.

Cardus Blog

  1. Plus ca change

    May 22, 2012 | Peter Stockland

    On today's 100th day of protests by Quebec students, Journal de Montreal columnist Richard Martineau offers a scabrous depiction of his province. Citing former Laval University ...
  2. Broken Union

    May 18, 2012 | Josh Reinders

    When the Quebec student protests started, my earliest feelings were of sympathy. These were fellow student, with whom I felt a kinship. Finally someone had taken up arms against...

Print Issue

  1. March 2012: Legacies
    Comment Magazine - Legacies Our culture does not know how to deal with legacies. We either treat the dead with some combination of awe and fear, or we think of our forebears as unworthy of remembrance, to ...