Comment Home / Reviews & Opinions

Closed Borders, Closed Minds

It is bad enough that we cannot get our act together about trading with other countries. Witness the continuing furor about the free trade agreement between Canada and the United States and the current discussion about the North American Free Trade Agreement.

What is even more puzzling, if not absurd, is that we continue to erect artificial barriers between provinces in this country. As we reported in the last issue of WRF Comment, Quebec has been at the forefront of protectionist activities, notably in the construction industry. It has perfected a maze of regulations that have virtually frozen out firms from other provinces. This has led to some nasty disputes between Quebec workers and politicians and their New Brunswick counterparts.

Originally, New Brunswick Premier Frank McKenna steadfastly refused to respond to the Quebec restrictions in kind out of a conviction that protectionism is self-defeating. However, the McKenna government has run out of patience and has been forced to fight back. In the words of Denis Losier, New Brunswick's Economic Development Minister, the province is now "doing exactly what they're doing in Quebec."

According to Losier, the real intention of these new regulations is to force Quebec to move faster in eliminating the barriers in favour of labour mobility. It is ironic that this announcement came right after the provinces appointed a team to begin negotiations for dismantling interprovincial trade barriers by the summer of 1994.

This is what ten years of frustration has come to, another reminder of how fragile the sense of Canadian nationhood is. And then there are those who think free trade with Mexico is what will destroy us.

Harry Antonides Harry Antonides
Harry Antonides is the founding editor of Comment. ... read more »


Add Your Comments


Copyright © 1974-2012 Cardus. All Rights Reserved.

| More

Feature Essays

  1. If Wishing Made it So: Teaching Students to Make Change

    May 14, 2012 | Gloria Stronks and Julia Stronks

    Parents and teachers want children to have the skills to make a difference. But what can we teach to help them survive their teen years, 20s, and 30s with convictions and charac...

Reviews & Opinions

  1. Do Not Open—No User Serviceable Parts Inside

    May 22, 2012 | David Greusel

    Why do so many of us have to work where the windows don't open? Engineers, architects, and lawyers have their reasons, but must workplaces be less humane than homes?
  2. Morality, markets, and Michael Sandel

    May 18, 2012 | Nick Spencer

    In Santa Ana in California prisoners can buy a cell upgrade. In Dallas, Texas, underachieving children are paid to read books. These are, alas, some of the saner and less offens...

Six Questions

  1. Saying "there is not enough time" is heresy

    May 2, 2012 | Stephanie Gehring

    SIX QUESTIONS . . . The new culture I am making is an attempt to say hold still and look at this.

Cardus Blog

  1. Plus ca change

    May 22, 2012 | Peter Stockland

    On today's 100th day of protests by Quebec students, Journal de Montreal columnist Richard Martineau offers a scabrous depiction of his province. Citing former Laval University ...
  2. Broken Union

    May 18, 2012 | Josh Reinders

    When the Quebec student protests started, my earliest feelings were of sympathy. These were fellow student, with whom I felt a kinship. Finally someone had taken up arms against...

Print Issue

  1. March 2012: Legacies
    Comment Magazine - Legacies Our culture does not know how to deal with legacies. We either treat the dead with some combination of awe and fear, or we think of our forebears as unworthy of remembrance, to ...