Comment Home / Reviews

For a Great Door is Opened

The legacy of Charlotte Mason, prolific educational pioneer.
For a great door for effective work has opened to me.
—I Corinthians 16:91

Sometimes, very rarely, we are gripped by an unforeseen encounter with a compelling person, provocative idea, or challenging experience, and the rush of life suddenly stills; our equipoise is regained only as we internalize the possible meaning and implications of the occurrence. For a time, we are on sacred ground—a great door into a large room has been opened for us. Whether through a conversation, print or digital media, or a personal or shared experience, we find ourselves examining the numinous encounter again and again.

Charlotte Mason, a nineteenth century British educator, was one of these singular encounters for me. She has attracted and kept my attention these many years as I've been a parent, high school teacher, and university educator. I met her following the 1995 Christmas holiday when my oldest child dropped out of kindergarten. In the midst of this very personal (what does one do with a five-year-old dropout?) and professional (my career teaching high school was well established) epistemic and pedagogical angst, a friend2 shared Susan Schaeffer Macaulay's 1984 book, For the Children's Sake: Foundations of Education for Home and School. I have never been the same.

Here, I'd like to peek through that great door at Mason's legacy. I will begin with a brief overview of Mason's impressive and lasting organizational accomplishments, then share some of her most compelling and essential ideas, and I conclude with a few thoughts on whether her design for education warrants our continued attention in twenty-first century education.3


Organizational Accomplishments

Charlotte Mason (1842-1923), a British educator and activist, had humble beginnings and was orphaned by age sixteen. After she attended one of the few institutions of the day where "teacher" certification might be obtained, Mason taught in a large infants' school, which took in over 200 children, and then taught in a "teacher training" institution herself. Beginning in her fifties, her quiet life became a veritable whirlwind of accomplishments and relationships that even today would be deemed impressive. She wrote extensively, established schools, developed curricula, founded a teachers' college, built lasting professional and personal friendships, and thought deeply. Mason's death was marked by a valuable memorial book and a service in London several months later wherein many testified that her presence was an inspiration and her quiet charm remarkable.

Mason's many writings include three series of works with topics ranging from geography to religion to education. The sales of the five-volume geography set, produced mostly in the 1880s, were modest. Her six volumes on education were frequently republished due to demand, and in 1905 the first five were published as a set under the title "Home Education Series" (Mason, 1886, 1896, 1904a, 1904b, 1905, 1923). Shortly after, Mason published six more works, between 1908 and 1914, mostly written in verse, on the Saviour of the world and the gospels.

Mason's educational volumes are without doubt the most important contribution to her enduring legacy. The first book in the education series was based on seven "Lectures to Ladies" which she offered (in lieu of a cash donation) in a parish charity event during the winter of 1885-1886. As it turns out, those lectures and the book they inspired were pivotal in her life. Very shortly thereafter, she founded a number of enduring educational organizations, institutions, and periodicals which also contribute substantially to her ongoing legacy.

Although the majority of the institutions and programs established by Mason quietly continued throughout the twentieth century, a notable rediscovery of her ideas has occurred in recent decades such that her ideas are, once again, being studied and practiced around the world. Schaeffer Macaulay (daughter of the famed mid-twentieth century Christian philosopher, Dr. Francis Schaeffer) played an important role in this rediscovery; she especially stimulated the interest of North Americans in Mason, particularly attracting the attention of home-educating parents. By her own account, as reported by Diane Lopez in her book Teaching Children (Crossway, 1988), Schaeffer Macaulay wrote For the Children's Sake when, after a decade of searching for a "satisfactory school" for their own children, she found "a small one-room private school in the back of a cottage in southern England . . . It was like watching a desert that had had the first rain in ten years." Once Schaeffer Macaulay discovered that this school was following Mason's design for education, she sought out and read Mason's original works.


Educational Ideas

The brunt of Mason's impact lay in the institutions she established and in her commitment to work with and through parents. Yet they hung together around several central ideas which, in 1904, in response to an organizational identity crisis, she succinctly fashioned into twenty points, her educational synopsis. What then did Mason see and expound in her conception of education? What was it that I—as a parent of a child who knew she was not being nurtured, nourished, and stimulated in school—found so attractive? From an era when the rights of each individual to equality of educational opportunity was being discussed and in a time when both home schoolrooms and schoolhouses were commonly dismal places of boredom and restriction, what was Mason proposing for education that could still be of interest in our times?

Mason's initial appeal often includes her practical strategies. In A Charlotte Mason Education (1996), Levison, for example, sums these:

[Mason] advocates a liberal (generous) education . . . Children should be educated by the humanities. [Mason] wants them to have a love for learning and for [the teacher] not to kill that love. We are leading them to self-education through direct contact with the best books, and the [masterly inactivity] of adults . . . We rely heavily on narration [verbal, written, modeled, demonstrated] instead of comprehension questions or workbooks to verify knowledge. Examinations are done with a view to see what the child does know, not to expose what they don't know . . . Short morning lessons [cover] a large variety of subjects . . . minds are invigorated by switching subjects . . . at fifteen-minute increments . . . all afternoon and evening [are] free to enjoy being a child, to pursue hobbies, and to read [and be outside].

Mason's motto for parents and other educators—"Education is an atmosphere, a discipline, a life"—also appeals. Atmosphere, habit formation and life setting are seen as the only things an adult may manipulate in a child's life. Other trinkets, such as stickers, extrinsic rewards, and even marks and grades are considered manipulative, unfair, and improper for an adult to administer.

At the risk of becoming too focused on technique or method, I must admit that I was warmed initially by the notion that I could trust my child's judgment and my child's own important, central role in her own education; yet on inspection, there was so much more. Mason explains that her Educational Synopsis (now printed in the preface of most republished versions of her educational volumes) embodies the "articles" of her "educational faith," and as such provides, I believe, the best basis on which to reconstruct an overview of her design for education. I have imputed seven themes onto the synopsis; this is my attempt to distil the essence of Mason's design for education. They provide key theoretical assumptions integral to any attempt to either understand or apply Mason's teachings. In my view, the seven themes below form the heart of Mason's education legacy.


View of the child. Children are born as persons but born neither good nor bad, with possibilities for good and evil. They are to be respected, and neither hindered, offended, nor despised through committed or omitted actions of adults.


Educational instruments. Although the child's obedience and the parent's or educator's authority is natural and necessary, and thus a fundamental principle, adults may not encroach upon the child's personality through fear, love, suggestion, influence, play upon natural desires, or any other means. Only three instruments in education can be used: natural atmosphere, discipline (intentionally developed habits of body and mind), and life (sustenance of the intellectual, moral, spiritual, and physical).


Mind and curriculum. The mind is not a receptacle or holding sac for finely prepared morsels of ideas, but is a spiritual organism, capable of digesting and assimilating a diet of all sorts of knowledge—in fact, the mind feeds on ideas and becomes malnourished if not properly fed. While in many systems the burden of education lies on the teacher, and thus the child may receive "much teaching with little knowledge," and it matters less what a child learns than how he learns it, it is here proposed that the child must be given a full and generous curriculum (a liberal education), and all knowledge that is presented to him must be vital, that is, facts must be presented with their informing ideas.


Nature of education. Education is the science of relations. The child has natural relations with a vast number of things and thoughts. Affinities that are wide and various must be established through all his training, out-of-door experiences, and through the child accessing many living books (up-to-date books by knowledgeable writers using a literary tone). Education is not about teaching all about anything, but is rather about establishing relations upon which future meetings will bring a thrill of recognition, a basis on which to develop further knowledge.


Behaviour of the mind. The mind requires sustenance, and knowledge will be that sustenance. It must be various and mainly conveyed in literary form. The mind assimilates knowledge only when it reproduces it or narrates it back. The mind is capable of great power of attention and therefore single readings are insisted on.


Moral and intellectual self-management. Children should be introduced to the two "secrets of moral and intellectual self-management"—the "Way of the Will" and the "Way of the Reason." In the first, they are taught to distinguish between "I want" and "I will." To will "effectively" they should turn their thoughts from their desires, distract or divert themselves for a while, and then the will will return to its work refreshed and vigorous. In the second, children are taught that reason can be fallible and that its purpose is to give logical demonstration of mathematical truth and of ideas initially accepted by the will. Reason will confirm whether initial ideas are right or wrong. Thus the child's chief responsibility is "the acceptance or rejection of initial ideas." The student will be aided in this by the principles of conduct, that is the formation of habits, and a wide range of knowledge.


Role of the divine Spirit in intellectual and spiritual life. Intellectual life and spiritual life are not separate—as Mason said, the "divine Spirit has constant access to their spirits and is their continual helper in all the interests, duties and joys of life."


These seven ideas are Mason's most profound gift to us and may be very briefly summarized as follows: Children are persons, born neither good nor evil; individuals to be respected and nourished by judicious adjustments of, and only of, the natural atmosphere (learning context), discipline (to inculcate good habits), and the properly sustained life. Because the child's mind is capable of assimilating all sorts of knowledge, especially when presented initially in a literary medium that gives life to thought, mind, and soul, and because the essence of education is forming and reforming relations between a wide and multifarious range of things, curriculum must be generous and liberal. Moral and intellectual self-management must be scaffolded so that children come to control what they actively will and recognize the fallibility of reason. Children and adults are in constant communion with the divine Spirit; thus the spiritual life cannot be lived separate from intellectual and practical life. A goal of education is to form a wealth of relationships to develop the ability to manage self and to recognize the helping presence of divine Spirit so as to be prepared and able to accept or reject initial ideas. This was Mason's vision—the essence of her, may I say, brilliant educational legacy.


Twenty-first Century Tenability

In my own journey as a parent and as an educator I have been deeply moved by Mason's example. Both her theoretical and practical accomplishments remain impressive—and given her gender and her times, they are outstanding. As a parent and teacher peeking for the first time through the great door that has been opened, I have found the coherence and "simplicity" of her proposals to answer a deep, unsettled feeling I've had about education in our times. Three of the points made above have become particularly meaningful to me as I have been involved in raising and educating my own children and as I work with teacher-education candidates. First, Mason's assertion (in 1885) that the child is a person—separate, sacred, responsible, capable, hungry, and eager to delight in knowledge—was a radical claim (note, for example, that women in Canada were declared to be "persons" only as recently as 1929). If we have ears to hear, I believe Mason's (1923) words still resonate:

Our crying need today is less for a better method of education than for an adequate conception of children . . . all action comes out of the ideas we hold and if we ponder duly upon personality we shall come to perceive that we cannot commit a greater offence than to maim or crush, or subvert any part of a person.

Second, Mason's assertion that the Divine Spirit cooperates in the unfolding of all of knowledge is part of her early thought and yet came together in 1893 in her Great Recognition. When reflecting before the Florentine fresco, The Descent of the Holy Spirit, she mused:

The great recognition that God, the Holy Spirit, is Himself personally the imparter of knowledge, instructor of youth, the inspirer of genius, is a conception so far lost to us that we should think it distinctly irreverent to conceive of the divine teaching as cooperating with ours in a child's arithmetic lesson, for example. But the Florentine mind of the Middle Ages went further than this. It believed, not only that the seven liberal arts were fully under the direct outpouring of the Holy Ghost, but that every fruitful idea, every original conception, whether in Euclid, or grammar, or music, was a direct inspiration from the Holy Spirit, without any thought at all as to whether the person so inspired named himself by the name of God, or recognized whence his inspiration came. All these seven figures [seated on the thrones representing the trivium and quadrivium] are those of persons whom we would roughly class as pagans, and whom we might be lightly inclined to consider as outside the pale of divine inspiration. It is truly difficult to grasp the amazing boldness of this scheme of the education of the world which Florence accepted in simple faith. (From Parents and Children: A Sequel to Home Education)

Third, Mason resolves that an important means for educating, given the anthropological and epistemological foundations of the two points above, involves the generous presentation of ideas to students through a large banquet of living books that will give life to thought, feeling, and soul—books that will normally have been written by those who have given original thought to the topic under consideration. "Ideas must reach us directly from the mind of the thinker and it is chiefly by means of the books they have written that we get in touch with the best minds"—the child must enjoy the book, and the ideas must make a sudden, delightful impact upon his or her mind.

There is absolutely no avenue to knowledge but knowledge itself, and the schools must begin, not by qualifying the mind to deal with knowledge, but by affording all the best books containing all the sorts of knowledge which [they want to know]. We have to face two difficulties. We do not believe in children as intellectual persons nor in knowledge as requisite and necessary for intellectual life.

It is tempting at this point to list favourite history, art, and nature books that have shaped my children throughout their years in a Charlotte Mason-inspired education, but I'll leave that for others more experienced and qualified in this area.

I am convinced Mason offers us still a coherent, comprehensive strategy for the education of children. She correctly asserts that there are few instruments of education available where educators observe the right of children to have their mind-hunger satisfied and their personality respected (and not undermined).

The instruments that can be legitimately invoked are atmosphere, discipline, and life— that is the natural environment in which a child lives his or her daily life, the habits they are guided to form, and the physical and mental sustenance offered to the child. Within such a framework, the teacher is to be a guide, philosopher, and friend; the student to be self-educating; the family charged to restore itself (where needed) to function as a miniature society or even nation; the parents to function as inspirers, revealers of God, schoolmasters, trainers, instructors in religion, teachers of morals, that use the senses and feelings; the curriculum to be generous and wide and presented in literary garb; the administration to support and equip parents; the schedule full of outdoor hours, with academic pursuits in the mornings, and afternoons for experience in handicrafts, nature study, field-work, drawing, music and physical (sports) pursuits, and evenings for reading and discussions.

What then is Mason's legacy? This peek through the door reveals—in theory and in practice—a coherent, conceptually integrated scheme with practical applications consistent with its informing ideas. As we reconsider education in our times, it seems to me that we ought to think about how to value the student more robustly as central to all learning and education, that we ought to direct some of our attention to the central epistemological thought that all fruitful ideas and every original conception finds its source in the Spirit of God, and thus ought to ask: "what forms will . . . [educational plans and strategies] take if there is true reciprocity and cooperation with the Spirit's enabling, sustaining, and developing power?" Finally, we ought to spend outrageous amounts of time and energy in creating the most nourishing educational environments possible and on writing, publishing, and celebrating the finest living books possible such that our next generation will be inspired to behave in certain ways—with generosity, resourcefulness, initiative, serviceableness, happiness, intelligence, magnanimity, self-dependence, self-orderliness, insightfulness, imagination, enthusiasm, sympathy, admiration, sound judgement, integrity, stability, attentiveness, reverence, and delight—and will be interested in a wide variety of ideas, topics, and pursuits—with an understanding of the inter-related aspects of life, the departments of knowledge (God, man and universe), and the subjects of thought.

Glimpsing through this great door has awakened the desire of educators across the world to re-imagine the vision for education in our times. Mason's remarkable personal and professional legacy demonstrates that with clarity, vision, energy, and community, much is possible. And so, in the unsettling moments when we observe the quiet grief of a "starving" five year old or recognize the hushed pain in our students' eyes and know that something is terribly amiss in the educational nourishment we are providing, Mason's legacy offers the courageous a compelling way forward.


Acknowledgements: Insightful comments by Laurie Bestvater, John Thorley, Jennifer Spencer, and Carroll Smith improved the content and accuracy of this paper. Their reviews are sincerely appreciated.


Notes

1 KJV version of this epigraph was used by W.G. de Burgh, Professor of Philosophy, University College, Reading, in his address at the Memorial Conference in March 1923 following Mason's death.

2 For this, I am indeed deeply indebted to Laurie Kenyon of Mitchell, Ontario.

3 My ongoing and sincere thanks and appreciation to Dr. Derek Allison and Dr. Fred Ellett both of the University of Western Ontario in London, Ontario for their supervision and guidance as I prepared a master's thesis on Mason's Design for Education. Much of what I write in this paper was originally shaped by that thesis.


References

Andreola, K. (1998). A Charlotte Mason companion: Personal reflections on the gentle art of learning. Elkton, MD: Charlotte Mason Research and Supply Company.

Armitt Library and Museum. (Present). Charlotte Mason Collection. Ambleside, UK: The Armitt.

Beckman, J. (2001). Charlotte Mason's applied philosophy of education and the theory and practice of student teaching—Four teachers' experiences (1949-1960): An oral history pilot study. Unpublished master of philosophy dissertation, University of Cambridge.

Beckman, J. (2004). Lessons to learn: Charlotte Mason's House of Education (1923-1960) and the resistance to taxonomic drift. Unpublished doctor of philosophy dissertation, University of Cambridge.

Bernier-Rodriguez, B. (2009). Education for the Kingdom: An exploration of the religious foundation of Charlotte Mason's educational philosophy. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Lancaster University, UK.

Chomondeley, E. (1960). The story of Charlotte Mason. Petersfield, Hants, UK: Child Light Publication.

Coombs, M. (1984). Some obstacles to the establishment of a universal method of education for parenthood by the PNEU. University of Aston, Birmingham: Unpublished master's thesis.

Cooper, E. (Ed.) (2004). When children love to learn: A practical application of Charlotte Mason's philosophy for today. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books.

De Burgh, W.G. (1923). "Some Impressions of the House of Education". In Parents' National Educational Union, In Memoriam: Charlotte M. Mason (pp. 100-105). London: Parents' National Educational Union.

Gardner, P. (1997). Charlotte Mason study guide: A simplified approach to a living education. Orem, UT: SunRise Publishing.

Inman, J. P. (1985). Charlotte Mason College. England: The Cormorant Press.

King, J. (1981). Charlotte Mason reviewed. Devon, England: Arthur H. Stockwell Ltd.

Levison, C. (1996). A Charlotte Mason education: A how-to manual. Beverly Hills, CA : Champion Press Ltd.

Levison, C. (2000). More Charlotte Mason education: A home schooling how-to manual. Beverly Hills, CA : Champion Press Ltd.

Lopez, D. (1988). Teaching children: A curriculum guide to what children need to know at each level through sixth grade. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books.

Mason, C.M. (1882). The Forty Shires: Their history, scenery, arts, and legends. 2nd ed. London: Hatchards, Piccadilly.

Mason, C.M. (1886). Home education: A course of lectures to ladies. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner, & Co. Ltd.

Mason, C.M. (1989/1896). Parents and children: A sequel to home education. Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House Publishers.

Mason, C.M. (1989/1904a). Home and School education: The training and education of children over nine. A book for parents and teachers. Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House Publishers.

Mason, C.M (1989/1904b). Ourselves: Self Knowledge (Book I) and Self Direction (Book II). Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House Publishers.

Mason, C.M. (1989/1905). Some Studies in the Formation of character. Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House Publishers.

Mason, C.M. (1925). An Essay Towards a philosophy of education: A liberal education for all. London: Kegan, Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co. Ltd.

Ney, M. W. (1999). Charlotte Mason: ‘a pioneer of sane education'. Nottingham, England: Educational Heretics Press.

Parents' National Educational Union. (1923). In memoriam Charlotte M. Mason. London, England: Rydal Press.

Rackliffe, K. Skidmore. (1998). Wild days: Creating discovery journals. Orem, Utah: SunRise Publishing.

Redeemer University College. (2009-2011). Charlotte Mason Digital Collection. At internet: www.redeemer.ca/charlotte-mason.

Schaeffer Macaulay, S. (1984). For the children's sake: Foundations of education for home and school. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books.

Smith, J. C. (2000). Charlotte Mason: An introductory analysis of her education theories and practices. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University.

Van Pelt, D.A. (2002). Charlotte Mason's design for education. Unpublished Master's Thesis, University of Western Ontario, London, Canada.

Van Pelt, D.A., Smith, J.C., Beckman, J., Thorley, J., Cadora, L., and Coombs, M. (2009-2010). Into the Digital Mirror: The Charlotte Mason Archives in an Information Age. Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. International Opportunities Fund. Project Grant.

Van Pelt, D.A., Smith, J.C., and Beckman, J.(2008-2009). Toward an international research agenda for the study of Charlotte Mason's philosophy of education. Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. International Opportunities Fund. Development Grant.

Wilson, E. (1987). Books children love: A guide to the best children's literature. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Books.

Help us spread the word:
Deani Van Pelt Deani Van Pelt
Deani A. Neven Van Pelt is Associate Professor of Education at Redeemer University College. ... read more »

Posted in Education, Institutions, Journalism, Legacy, Parenting. Linked to Cardus' Education research project.

Subscribe to the Comment Weekly Newsletter
Comment's online articles serve as bridges between print issues. Get an email in your inbox every Friday, so you don't miss out.
  • Stay up-to-date and informed
  • Only one concise digest email per week
  • We will never share your email address. No Spam!
We will never sell or rent your email address. Your privacy is important to us

Related Articles

We'd love to hear your comments. Tell us what you think of this article! We'll use the best comments in Comment's print edition, and top commenters each month will receive a free, signed copy of our editor's recent book: Discipleship in the Present Tense.

Copyright © 1974-2014 Cardus. All Rights Reserved.

This Article Belongs To ...

  1. March 2012: Legacies
    Comment Magazine - Legacies Our culture does not know how to deal with legacies. We either treat the dead with some combination of awe and fear, or we think of our forebears as unworthy of remembrance, to be cast behind our own pursuits and discoveries.

    Christians, however, can take a different tack. Ours is a historical faith, containing gifts each generation must re-open—some to be treasured, some to be viewed and sent back.

    In this issue of Comment, we reject both our tendencies to ignore and to idolize the past. Instead, we seek to draw the good out of legacies, as we acknowledge that all legacies east of Eden will always be, at best, mixed.

    How will you respond to the gifts of these legacies in your own life and work?
Buy this issue »

Features

  1. Grinding Through the Pleasure Factory: Reading Arendt at Disney World

    August 28, 2014 | Mike Cosper

    Disney World is an entertainment happiness factory, and darn it, it actually seems to work.

Reviews

  1. Beyond "Engagement": The Next Conversation We Need About Politics

    May 1, 2014 | James K.A. Smith

    Looking elsewhere for the robust embrace of politics that will speak today—to our time and place and audience.
  2. Getting Back to Place

    April 24, 2014 | Doug Sikkema

    Because place has such a power to shape, we must be mindful of how we shape our places.

Cardus Blog

  1. The Haunting Presence of Time in Linklater’s Boyhood

    August 26, 2014 | Doug Sikkema

    There’s a sadness that runs through Richard Linklater’s recent film Boyhood, one that’s hard to put your finger on. Shot over twelve years—yes, twelve years!—t...
  2. Expand the Inner Circles

    August 21, 2014 | Brian Dijkema

    Earlier this month, Robert George offered a bit of advice to young scholars. That advice, in a nutshell, is to be very wary of applause. "In the end," he says, "what matters ...

Print Issue

  1. September 2014: Cracks in the Secular
    Comment Magazine - Cracks in the Secular An injection of hope: the fall issue of Comment will seriously challenge and confront the attempt of some to reconfigure North American public life in a way that diminishes and ...
Comment on iPad