The best of Comment

August 2005


| More

Comment Magazine - The best of Comment

05

The Flash of a Fish Knife

By Calvin Seerveld

My father is a seller of fish. We children know the business too having worked from childhood in the Great South Bay Fish Market, Patchogue, Long Island, New York, helping our father like a quiver full of arrows. It is a small store, and it smells like fish.

06

Market economy? Yes! Market society? No!

By Gideon Strauss

Here at the Work Research Foundation we believe in markets. We believe markets to be the best way—no, the only sane way—to structure interactions in economic life. But this does not mean we support the idea of a market society—what Warren Bennis calls "a bottom-line society."

08

Character and Productivity

By Walter C. Wright Jr.

What is the most important thing in life to you? When your life is over and you look back—what do you want to be known for? The answers to these questions are visible today in the productivity and profitability of your company. There is a connection between the values that you hold—your character—and the productivity or success of your company.

10

Work

By Michael Van Pelt

Okay, you would think by now we would have this work thing all figured out. Besides sleep, it occupies more of our day than any other activity. We are often very good at it. But as an exercise for thinking about work, try answering the following questions: Why do I work? For what good do I work? When should I work?

12

Gifts from "Father Abraham"

By Vincent Bacote

While it is indeed more than worthwhile to mine the riches of faith that we have because of Abraham's obedience to God, I have a different Abraham in mind: Abraham Kuyper. I mean no blasphemy by labelling Kuyper in a manner similar to the father of the faith, and it is true that his aim of making a place in Dutch society for the kleine luyden (the little people) made him more like a Moses figure.

14

Neocalvinism and Social Justice

By David T. Koyzis

There is a rather quaint way of describing the modern maldistribution of the world's goods between haves and have-nots. The fact that some people live in want while others live comfortably—that some go to bed hungry while others risk obesity—is summed up in this term: the social question.

17

The DNA of Economic Life

By Gideon Strauss

The struggle against poverty, the effort of work, the building of companies and labour unions—all of these are about cultivating the sphere of economic life so that it is both intrinsically healthy and able to provide the means by which we can take care of our non-economic responsibilities.

21

The anti-anti-Americanism we need now

By Gideon Strauss

While I think that there is a cultural or aesthetic anti-Americanism and an anti-capitalist anti-Americanism that deserves separate attention, it is clear that the most powerful anti-Americanism of our time is indeed aimed against the creedal Americanism identified by Mr. Gelernter. It is an anti-Americanism I cannot support and for which I feel disdain in its small-minded envious forms and disgust in its raveningly malevolent forms.

25

Sphere Sovereignty 101

By Ray Pennings and James Brink

I stepped back from the board so that they all could see as I contrasted the rights-model with the alternative model I was outlining. . . . We participate in a vast array of social structures: families, businesses, unions, churches, schools. Yet despite the immense influence that these institutions wield, their roles, privileges, and obligations are not addressed in the social contract.

30

The poor are not the problem

By Gideon Strauss

Many poor countries have the appearance of market economies but are actually mercantilist economies, with small elites enriching themselves through government favours, contracts, and privileges while excluding and marginalizing both local and foreign competitors by government means . . .

35

Beyond Unions?

By Ray Pennings

The real question, then, may not be the question of union decline and revival, but rather the question of how to adapt our structures and public policy to accommodate the emerging forms of worker organization.

41

The Failure of the New York Intellectuals

By Daniel Silliman

The failure of the New York Intellectuals, finally—after a life in the American public as critics and theorists, pundits and intellectuals—was the failure to pass on a tradition. They became but a historical quirk when they failed to bequeath the tradition onto another generation and another age.

49

H. Evan Runner and the Groen Club

By Harry Van Dyke

He came to the expectant members with an ambitious program of study. It was designed to be a systematic approach to delving into the meaning of the Reformed or Calvinist religion in all its ramifications for the life of service that students were preparing for, whether that be in science, business, the gospel ministry, medicine, law, or education.

This Issue

Every few decades a magazine emerges that reinvigorates the North American public intellectual scene, and eventually reshapes the political and cultural landscape. In the 1930s it was the Partisan Review's amalgam of Trotsky's politics and Eliot's poetry. In the 1970s it was Commentary's cold warrior/supply sider/traditional values neoconservatism. Comment can do this job in the early 21st century—provided we become the journal of choice of tomorrow's Christian leaders while they are still in college.

This issue of Comment is special in the sense that the scope of issues addressed and the points of view articulated have been selected to represent the mission and character of the Work Research Foundation (now Cardus). The mission of Cardus is to influence people toward a Christian view of work and public life. In this issue you will find a Christian view of work and public life articulated in a wide variety of ways, and by a rich array of voices. You will read about various situations in which these issues have been thrashed out—including among fishmongers and labour unions, student groups and city intellectuals.

Get Comment for yourself

RSS Feed

Stay current with Comment - subscribe to our RSS feed.